Goodwin: Proposed insurance rate hike ‘discriminatory’

By on February 19, 2014


Major damage is infrequent on the Outer Banks, which is slated for the biggest rate increase. (Missie Smith, Voice file)

Calling another round of proposed rate increases “excessive and unfairly discriminatory,” N.C. Insurance Commissioner Wayne Goodwin has ordered homeowners insurance companies to explain at hearing in August why they want the hike.

The North Carolina Rate Bureau, which represents insurance companies that write policies in the state, submitted an average statewide increase in homeowners policy rates of 25.3 percent, with increases of over 30 percent in many coastal counties.

The rate request was filed on Jan. 3, coming on the heels of a 7 percent average statewide increase in premiums that took effect last July.

Locally, the average increase last year was as high as 17 percent in coastal Currituck, Hyde and Dare counties.

In a press release, Goodwin’s office said the filing uses hypothetical rather than actual data.

Goodwin added that when calculating costs, including those for the net costs of reinsurance and trended modeled hurricane loses, the filing lacks necessary data, documentation and explanations to meet a statutory burden of proof for increases.

He also said old data was used in the filing when more recent data should be available and included in the analysis.

Over 10,000 written public comments were submitted on the proposal in January, while 25 people spoke at a public comments session on Jan. 24.

The hearing is scheduled for Aug. 6, at 10 a.m. at 430 N. Salisbury Street in Raleigh. The public can attend, but there will be no opportunity to provide input.

The case against the rate increase will be presented by experts from the NCDOI, while experts from the N.C. Rate Bureau will present the insurers case.

Goodwin will serve as the hearing officer and will determine what, if any, rate increases are warranted.

Under North Carolina law, his decision can be appealed through the state courts if the insurance companies do not agree with his determination.

Bookmark and Share



February 21, 2014 9:18 pm

Since a homeowner policy will not pay for flood damage or wind damage in Dare County, we must be a greater risk for fire or theft? I fail to see the logic for the increase.


February 21, 2014 11:01 am


February 20, 2014 10:27 am

Just prior to the election in 2012 NC Insurance Commissioner Wayne Goodwin promised the good people of NC that he would hold a hearing over the newly requested wind and hail insurance rate hike. After the election he canceled the hearing. His own words were that he wanted to save the state money by not having the hearing. Well, what about the money we coastal taxpayers have to fork over for these outrageous rates?!! Is saving money for the state more important to Commissioner Goodwin than saving money for coastal taxpayers? My premium went up 17% – how about yours?

On the surface it appears mighty suspicious. It appears to be politically motivated. Goodwin gets more votes from the urban western parts of the state and they get smaller premiums. Goodwin cancels the promised hearing after he is narrowly re-elected.

Let’s hold Commissioner Goodwin to a rate hike hearing – and a thorough one – this time. It is overdue. A reform of the office is overdue.

Join the discussion:

You must login to post a comment.

Not registered? Create an account.